Amazon’s ambitious adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth legendarium, The Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power, returned for its second season amidst high hopes and lingering skepticism. Unfortunately, the first four episodes have done little to alleviate the concerns that plagued the inaugural season. Despite a promising premise and stunning visuals, the show’s meandering pacing, underdeveloped characters, and creative liberties have continued to disappoint fans and critics alike. With few memorable moments to speak of, the season has thus far failed to live up to its full potential. But can Episode 5 be the turning point that rights the ship? Let’s dive in and find out if this latest installment can redeem the season’s lackluster start.
Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 Episode 5 Review – Worst of the Series
Rating – ★★
Sadly, Episode 5 doesn’t just continue to be disappointing – it reaches a new level of bad, eclipsing its predecessors by leagues. This instalment is a blatant waste of viewers’ time, failing to progress any meaningful plot points and instead meandering through inconsequential events. The Numenor arc, already the most detestable aspect of the series, continues to test fans’ patience with its relentless tedium. It’s as if the creators are intentionally showcasing the most unpopular elements, almost mocking the audience’s discontent. Seriously, no one cares about the politics of Numenor and those who do are being disappointed by the sheer incompetency of the writing involved in this arc.
Also, the episode’s narrative vacuum is staggering, with Valandil’s demise serving as a prime example. His passing is highly inconsequential and leaves no impact, which is a testament to the show’s inability to craft memorable characters. Umm, who was Valandil again? Furthermore, The Stranger’s storyline, which was finally getting interesting is conspicuously absent, leaving fans wondering why last episode’s most promising setup was neglected. Similarly, the Nori and Stoors subplot, mercifully absent, but thank God for that as Nori’s arc remains the second-most cringeworthy aspect of the series. The sole redeeming arc of Season 2, aka, Arondir and Isildur’s arc, is also nowhere to be found, which reflects the makers’ absolute lack of vision of how to keep viewers interested.
We also spend some time this episode at Kazad-dum, and frankly, Durin and his father’s dynamic too has now become very repetitive and uninteresting. The Balrog was awoken in the season 1 finale, yet 5 episodes in, we’ve received no updates regarding him. Galadriel and Adar also remained largely absent from the episode only showing up in final 1 minute to deliver the episode ending line (which they probably thought was epic? Huhh). With only three episodes remaining, the prospect of redemption seems increasingly unlikely. It’s a travesty that a show boasting breath-taking visuals, masterful cinematography, and a sublime soundtrack can be so narratively bankrupt. The disconnect between aesthetics and storytelling is jarring! Yawning and dozing off while such heavenly audio-visual experience in on display feels like a huge disrespect, but you can’t help it.
It’s baffling that a show with such immense potential can squander it so spectacularly. The source material is rich and beloved, yet the adaptation fails to capture its essence. The show’s inability to balance action, drama, and character development is just disheartening. The pacing is plodding, the dialogue is clunky, and the plot twists are predictable. It’s a mess of epic proportions, and it’s hard to see how they can recover from this. The question remains: why can’t the creators hire competent writers and directors to do justice to Tolkien’s legacy?
Final Verdict – The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power Season 2 Episode 5 is certainly the worst of this season and potentially the worst this series has to offer. Don’t be too sure however, the worst may yet arrive as we continue with this poorly envisioned series.
If you have any questions regarding LOTR: The Rings of Power, feel free to ask in the comments below. For more content, stay tuned. As usual, like, subscribe and share our articles as we here are trying to build a community of people High on Cinema!
